Sold Cards Prices from all card games
MTG Cards Card database, rulings & prices
Theme
Any Word, Any Order

Search returns matches with any word, regardless of order: wrath of god and god wrath of return the same results.

Exclude Terms

Use minus to exclude: charizard -japanese

Narrow Results

Add more terms: wrath of god revised

Exact Phrases

Use quotes for exact matching: "wrath of god"

View Full Search Guide
React to this search
Share an emoji or a quick note about “1998 MTG EXODUS #72 RECURRING NIGHTMARE PSA 9”
36 sold · Avg $57.56
# Sold
36
Avg Price
$57.56
Median
$60.00
Trimmed Avg
$56.87
excl. outliers
30-Day Avg
$80.00
2 sales
90-Day Avg
$68.74
6 sales
Medium
Recurring Nightmare #72 (NM) Exodus EXO Magic MTG - Image 1Recurring Nightmare #72 (NM) Exodus EXO Magic MTG - Image 2
USJun 03, 2026Sold
$95.99
View Listing
Recurring Nightmare Exodus MTG Rare Black Enchantment Regular English 1998 - Image 1Recurring Nightmare Exodus MTG Rare Black Enchantment Regular English 1998 - Image 2
USJun 02, 2026Sold
$64.00
View Listing
MTG Magic the Gathering Recurring Nightmare 72 Exodus - Image 1MTG Magic the Gathering Recurring Nightmare 72 Exodus - Image 2
USMay 16, 2026Sold
$69.00
View Listing
Magic The Gathering Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72/143 MTG - Image 1Magic The Gathering Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72/143 MTG - Image 2
USApr 25, 2026Sold
$61.99
View Listing
Magic The Gathering MTG Recurring Nightmare 72 HP Exodus - Image 1
CAApr 21, 2026Sold
$58.44
View Listing
Wizards of the Coast MTG Recurring Nightmare Exodus 72/143 - Image 1Wizards of the Coast MTG Recurring Nightmare Exodus 72/143 - Image 2
USApr 10, 2026Sold
$63.00
Best Offer Accepted
View Listing
Recurring Nightmare–Exodus 1998–Reserved List Rare–Vintage MTG-Original Printing - Image 1Recurring Nightmare–Exodus 1998–Reserved List Rare–Vintage MTG-Original Printing - Image 2Recurring Nightmare–Exodus 1998–Reserved List Rare–Vintage MTG-Original Printing - Image 3Recurring Nightmare–Exodus 1998–Reserved List Rare–Vintage MTG-Original Printing - Image 4Recurring Nightmare–Exodus 1998–Reserved List Rare–Vintage MTG-Original Printing - Image 5
USMar 05, 2026Sold
$53.00$40.00
Best Offer Accepted
1x MTG Recurring Nightmare - Exodus (EXO) #72 - Magic the Gathering - Image 11x MTG Recurring Nightmare - Exodus (EXO) #72 - Magic the Gathering - Image 2
USFeb 21, 2026Sold
$69.99
Vintage 1998 MTG Exodus Recurring Nightmare Card Near Mint - Image 1Vintage 1998 MTG Exodus Recurring Nightmare Card Near Mint - Image 2Vintage 1998 MTG Exodus Recurring Nightmare Card Near Mint - Image 3Vintage 1998 MTG Exodus Recurring Nightmare Card Near Mint - Image 4Vintage 1998 MTG Exodus Recurring Nightmare Card Near Mint - Image 5
USFeb 19, 2026Sold
$83.00
Magic: The Gathering Recurring Nightmare Enchantment Exodus Rare Regular 72 1998 - Image 1Magic: The Gathering Recurring Nightmare Enchantment Exodus Rare Regular 72 1998 - Image 2
USFeb 16, 2026Sold
$55.00
Vintage 1998 MTG Exodus Recurring Nightmare Card Near Mint Magic The Gathering - Image 1Vintage 1998 MTG Exodus Recurring Nightmare Card Near Mint Magic The Gathering - Image 2Vintage 1998 MTG Exodus Recurring Nightmare Card Near Mint Magic The Gathering - Image 3Vintage 1998 MTG Exodus Recurring Nightmare Card Near Mint Magic The Gathering - Image 4
USFeb 08, 2026Sold
$69.99
Vintage 1998 MTG Exodus Recurring Nightmare Card Near Mint - Image 1Vintage 1998 MTG Exodus Recurring Nightmare Card Near Mint - Image 2Vintage 1998 MTG Exodus Recurring Nightmare Card Near Mint - Image 3Vintage 1998 MTG Exodus Recurring Nightmare Card Near Mint - Image 4Vintage 1998 MTG Exodus Recurring Nightmare Card Near Mint - Image 5
USJan 31, 2026Sold
$84.00$70.00
Best Offer Accepted
Magic The Gathering MTG Recurring Nightmare 72 HP Exodus - Image 1
CAJan 22, 2026Sold
$39.75$39.89
Best Offer Accepted
Magic The Gathering MTG Recurring Nightmare 72 #B Exodus - Image 1Magic The Gathering MTG Recurring Nightmare 72 #B Exodus - Image 2
CAJan 21, 2026Sold
$64.49$64.51
Best Offer Accepted
Recurring Nightmare Japanese Magic: Exodus #72 1998 - Image 1Recurring Nightmare Japanese Magic: Exodus #72 1998 - Image 2
USJan 21, 2026Sold
$39.35
Magic The Gathering MTG Recurring Nightmare 72 #C Exodus - Image 1Magic The Gathering MTG Recurring Nightmare 72 #C Exodus - Image 2
CAJan 18, 2026Sold
$47.79
Recurring Nightmare 72/143 Exodus MTG Card 1998 - Image 1Recurring Nightmare 72/143 Exodus MTG Card 1998 - Image 2Recurring Nightmare 72/143 Exodus MTG Card 1998 - Image 3
USJan 15, 2026Sold
$60.00
Magic The Gathering MTG Recurring Nightmare 72 #A Exodus - Image 1Magic The Gathering MTG Recurring Nightmare 72 #A Exodus - Image 2
CAJan 12, 2026Sold
$47.79
MTG Recurring Nightmare 72/143 Exodus Card 1998 - Image 1MTG Recurring Nightmare 72/143 Exodus Card 1998 - Image 2
USJan 05, 2026Sold
$66.00$60.00
Best Offer Accepted
MTG Recurring Nightmare Japanese Exodus 72/143 Regular Rare Card - Image 1MTG Recurring Nightmare Japanese Exodus 72/143 Regular Rare Card - Image 2MTG Recurring Nightmare Japanese Exodus 72/143 Regular Rare Card - Image 3
USDec 25, 2025Sold
$59.99$45.00
Best Offer Accepted
Recurring Nightmare Exodus Magic Karte MTG englisch (Ewiger Albtraum) 72/143 - Image 1Recurring Nightmare Exodus Magic Karte MTG englisch (Ewiger Albtraum) 72/143 - Image 2Recurring Nightmare Exodus Magic Karte MTG englisch (Ewiger Albtraum) 72/143 - Image 3Recurring Nightmare Exodus Magic Karte MTG englisch (Ewiger Albtraum) 72/143 - Image 4
DEDec 19, 2025Sold
$47.47
Recurring Nightmare - Exodus #72/143 MTG Magic The Gathering - Image 1Recurring Nightmare - Exodus #72/143 MTG Magic The Gathering - Image 2Recurring Nightmare - Exodus #72/143 MTG Magic The Gathering - Image 3Recurring Nightmare - Exodus #72/143 MTG Magic The Gathering - Image 4Recurring Nightmare - Exodus #72/143 MTG Magic The Gathering - Image 5
USDec 16, 2025Sold
$49.98
1998 Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72 NM - Image 11998 Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72 NM - Image 2
USDec 07, 2025Sold
$35.99
Recurring Nightmare - Korean (Exodus, Rare, 1998) MTG LP Foreign - Image 1Recurring Nightmare - Korean (Exodus, Rare, 1998) MTG LP Foreign - Image 2
USDec 04, 2025Sold
$84.99
Recurring Nightmare Exodus 1998 Near Mint Never Played Magic The Gathering Mtg - Image 1Recurring Nightmare Exodus 1998 Near Mint Never Played Magic The Gathering Mtg - Image 2Recurring Nightmare Exodus 1998 Near Mint Never Played Magic The Gathering Mtg - Image 3Recurring Nightmare Exodus 1998 Near Mint Never Played Magic The Gathering Mtg - Image 4Recurring Nightmare Exodus 1998 Near Mint Never Played Magic The Gathering Mtg - Image 5
USNov 12, 2025Sold
$64.98

Login required

Please log in or sign up to react or comment.