Sold Cards Prices from all card games
MTG Cards Card database, rulings & prices
Theme
Any Word, Any Order

Search returns matches with any word, regardless of order: wrath of god and god wrath of return the same results.

Exclude Terms

Use minus to exclude: charizard -japanese

Narrow Results

Add more terms: wrath of god revised

Exact Phrases

Use quotes for exact matching: "wrath of god"

View Full Search Guide
React to this search
Share an emoji or a quick note about “Toothy, Imaginary Friend”
56 sold · Avg $13.47
# Sold
56
Avg Price
$13.47
Median
$9.98
Trimmed Avg
$12.18
excl. outliers
30-Day Avg
$13.51
9 sales
90-Day Avg
$12.87
29 sales
Medium
Toothy Imaginary Friend 012/254 - Battlebond- Regular - MTG - NM - Image 1Toothy Imaginary Friend 012/254 - Battlebond- Regular - MTG - NM - Image 2
USMar 31, 2026Sold
$12.90
Best Offer Accepted
View Listing
Toothy Imaginary Friend (Borderless) Secret Lair Drop Foil 1049 NM+ Unplayed MTG - Image 1Toothy Imaginary Friend (Borderless) Secret Lair Drop Foil 1049 NM+ Unplayed MTG - Image 2
USMar 26, 2026Sold
$26.99
View Listing
Toothy, Imaginary Friend – Battlebond (BBD) – Foil – NM – Magic The Gathering MT - Image 1
USMar 24, 2026Sold
$10.62
View Listing
1x Toothy, Imaginary Friend Moderate Play MTG Magic - Kid Icarus - - Image 1
USMar 24, 2026Sold
$9.40
View Listing
Toothy, Imaginary Friend - Battlebond: #12, Magic: The Gathering Nm R151 - Image 1
USMar 16, 2026Sold
$9.07
View Listing
Toothy, Imaginary Friend - Battlebond - Rare - MTG - Magic The Gathering - Image 1Toothy, Imaginary Friend - Battlebond - Rare - MTG - Magic The Gathering - Image 2Toothy, Imaginary Friend - Battlebond - Rare - MTG - Magic The Gathering - Image 3Toothy, Imaginary Friend - Battlebond - Rare - MTG - Magic The Gathering - Image 4
USMar 15, 2026Sold
$9.97
View Listing
Toothy, Imaginary Friend - Battlebond - Rare - MTG - Magic The Gathering - Image 1Toothy, Imaginary Friend - Battlebond - Rare - MTG - Magic The Gathering - Image 2Toothy, Imaginary Friend - Battlebond - Rare - MTG - Magic The Gathering - Image 3Toothy, Imaginary Friend - Battlebond - Rare - MTG - Magic The Gathering - Image 4
USMar 12, 2026Sold
$9.97
View Listing
MYG: Toothy, Imaginary Friend BORDERLESS FOIL, NM Secret Lair Drop Chase Card!! - Image 1MYG: Toothy, Imaginary Friend BORDERLESS FOIL, NM Secret Lair Drop Chase Card!! - Image 2MYG: Toothy, Imaginary Friend BORDERLESS FOIL, NM Secret Lair Drop Chase Card!! - Image 3
USMar 10, 2026Sold
$19.99
View Listing
MTG - BBD 11 & 12 - Pir, Imaginative Rascal & Toothy, Imaginary Friend - NM - Image 1
USMar 09, 2026Sold
$12.69
View Listing
Magic: The Gathering Toothy Imaginary Friend Creature Battlebond 012/254 LP - Image 1Magic: The Gathering Toothy Imaginary Friend Creature Battlebond 012/254 LP - Image 2
USMar 02, 2026Sold
$8.00
View Listing
2018 MAGIC THE GATHERING BATTLEBOND 12 TOOTHY IMAGINARY FRIEND PRERELEASE PSA 10 - Image 12018 MAGIC THE GATHERING BATTLEBOND 12 TOOTHY IMAGINARY FRIEND PRERELEASE PSA 10 - Image 2
USMar 02, 2026Sold
$14.50
View Listing
MTG - Toothy, Imaginary Friend Secret Lair Drop Borderless M/NM - Image 1MTG - Toothy, Imaginary Friend Secret Lair Drop Borderless M/NM - Image 2
USFeb 26, 2026Sold
$17.00
View Listing
Magic: The Gathering Toothy Imaginary Friend Creature Battlebond 012/254 Regula… - Image 1Magic: The Gathering Toothy Imaginary Friend Creature Battlebond 012/254 Regula… - Image 2
USFeb 25, 2026Sold
$8.50
View Listing
1x (MP) Toothy, Imaginary Friend ~Japanese~ Moderately Played JP Battlebond MTG - Image 11x (MP) Toothy, Imaginary Friend ~Japanese~ Moderately Played JP Battlebond MTG - Image 2
USFeb 24, 2026Sold
$6.99
View Listing
MTG Toothy, Imaginary Friend Battlebond 012/254 Regular Rare - Image 1MTG Toothy, Imaginary Friend Battlebond 012/254 Regular Rare - Image 2MTG Toothy, Imaginary Friend Battlebond 012/254 Regular Rare - Image 3MTG Toothy, Imaginary Friend Battlebond 012/254 Regular Rare - Image 4MTG Toothy, Imaginary Friend Battlebond 012/254 Regular Rare - Image 5
USFeb 20, 2026Sold
$9.99
View Listing
Magic the Gathering MTG Toothy, Imaginary Friend Battlebond LP - Image 1Magic the Gathering MTG Toothy, Imaginary Friend Battlebond LP - Image 2
USFeb 20, 2026Sold
$9.95
View Listing
mtg battlebond pir, imaginative rascal & Toothy, Imaginary Friend NM unplayed - Image 1mtg battlebond pir, imaginative rascal & Toothy, Imaginary Friend NM unplayed - Image 2mtg battlebond pir, imaginative rascal & Toothy, Imaginary Friend NM unplayed - Image 3mtg battlebond pir, imaginative rascal & Toothy, Imaginary Friend NM unplayed - Image 4
USFeb 15, 2026Sold
$15.00
View Listing
Toothy, Imaginary Friend Battlebond Regular - Image 1Toothy, Imaginary Friend Battlebond Regular - Image 2
USFeb 14, 2026Sold
$8.65
View Listing
[1x] Toothy, Imaginary Friend Near Mint, English Battlebond MTG Magic - Image 1
USFeb 10, 2026Sold
$8.60
View Listing
2022 MTG Magic the Gathering SLD Secret Lair Foil #1049 Toothy Imaginary Friend - Image 12022 MTG Magic the Gathering SLD Secret Lair Foil #1049 Toothy Imaginary Friend - Image 2
USFeb 06, 2026Sold
$29.99
View Listing
[MTG] Toothy, Imaginary Friend (012) (BBD) NM - Image 1
GBFeb 06, 2026Sold
$13.52$9.00
Best Offer Accepted
View Listing
Toothy, Imaginary Friend NM Battlebond BBD 12 / 254 MTG English Regular Partner - Image 1Toothy, Imaginary Friend NM Battlebond BBD 12 / 254 MTG English Regular Partner - Image 2Toothy, Imaginary Friend NM Battlebond BBD 12 / 254 MTG English Regular Partner - Image 3Toothy, Imaginary Friend NM Battlebond BBD 12 / 254 MTG English Regular Partner - Image 4Toothy, Imaginary Friend NM Battlebond BBD 12 / 254 MTG English Regular Partner - Image 5
USFeb 02, 2026Sold
$9.47
View Listing
MTG FOIL Toothy, Imaginary Friend Battlebond Magic the Gathering - Image 1MTG FOIL Toothy, Imaginary Friend Battlebond Magic the Gathering - Image 2
USFeb 02, 2026Sold
$9.99
View Listing
Toothy, Imaginary Friend (Borderless) -Foil Light Play MTG Secret Lair - Image 1
USJan 31, 2026Sold
$22.96
View Listing
MTG Toothy, Imaginary Friend - 12 / English / Near Mint - Image 1
CAJan 23, 2026Sold
$9.57
View Listing

Login required

Please log in or sign up to react or comment.